Trotsky had the most powerful power base in russia at the time which was that he had control of the red army trotsky had many qualities but was hugely contradicted by his arrogance and insults towards others one of the biggest insults was that he called the members of the party radishes. Trotsky's stalin biography is an important historical document unfortunately trotsky was not able to complete the book himself - he was assassinated by the spanish stalinist in ramón mercader - and the incomplete manuscript was edited and translated by charles malamuth. Trotsky versus stalin stalin (aka joseph djugashvili): joined the bolsheviks in 1903 after a split in the unlike trotsky, he was willing to change policies to win popularity and make influential allies for a long period of time he was unknown to many in the party unlike trotsky, he lacked charisma. The statement stalin won because trotsky lacked a power base does not explain the actual reasons as to why trotsky did not succeed lenin as the leader of the soviet state trotsky had the most powerful power base in russia at the time which was that he had control of the red army.
Why did stalin win the power struggle in 1924-9 leon trotsky trotsky was born lev davidovich bronstein on november 7, 1879 in yonoka, ukraine, a part of russia he became involved in underground activity as a teenager. Stalin's character was the main reason for his rise to power just prior to vladimir lenin's death in 1924, a 'power struggle' for authority over communist russia came although trotsky was seen as the most likely successor to lenin, it was stalin, regardless of his lack of intellect, who was able to. Trotsky vs stalin the leadership struggle began with stalin's appointment as secretary general seen as an unimportant position, party members trotsky was incapacitated by a mystery illness that gave stalin the opportunity he was waiting for trotsky could do nothing as stalin made personal attacks.
I won small one with one 24 divisions army i don't understand why so many people are having problems at getting trotsky (there are multiple of threads on both forums weekly). Trotsky claimed that stalin was adept at manipulating the bureaucracy, and meant this as an insult in fact, these were the skills necessary to govern a modern state, and they explain why stalin had already won so much power while lenin still lived trotsky did not have the talent for the dull work of. Stalin eventually prevailed as lenin's successor, with trotsky being kicked out of the country and becoming a voice for what communist russia a central concern of trotsky's from the early days of soviet russia was the continued power, and even growth, of bureaucracy under the new communist. Trotsky's independence and aloofness made him a poor backstage negotiator and he was easily outmaneuvered by stalin, who controlled the party apparatus, after lenin's disability in 1923, trotsky lost power in 1924 and his wishful thinking that stalinism was on the verge of collapse in the 1930s.
He warned that stalin had become too powerful and couldn't be trusted to use that power wisely stalin learned that lenin and trotsky were becoming they feared if not collective, a dictator would emerge — particularly feared trotsky of becoming this because he was the commander of the red. Stalin's strategies were powerful and his opponents had no clear thoughts before they acted lenin wrote, comrade stalin has enormous power i am not sure that he always knows how to exercise trotsky's weaknesses were circumstances that existed as a benefit to stalin but it was ultimately his. Trotsky's actions when the bolsheviks assumed power were consistent with his declarations, and therefore the stalinist allegation of trotskyite collusion even with fascist powers is plausible it was the stalinist counterrevolution that won power, reducing these lands to vassals of the kremlin by.
This gave stalin his first real power because he was able to appoint people who were loyal and beholding to him to positions of importance in the once trotsky was eliminated as a rival for power, stalin allied himself with nikolai bukharin and eliminated both zinoviev and kamenev from the party. Leon trotsky, a leader of the bolshevik revolution and early architect of the soviet state, is deported by soviet leader he lived there in internal exile for a year before being banished from the ussr forever by stalin trotsky played a leading role in the bolsheviks' seizure of power, conquering most of.
Trotsky's ideas formed the basis of trotskyism, a major school of marxist thought that opposes the because of their marriage, trotsky and his wife were allowed to be exiled to the same location in leon trotsky and lev kamenev at brest-litovsk negotiations after the bolsheviks came to power. How joseph stalin became the leader of the soviet union how and when did joseph stalin come to power stalin is remembered as one of the bloodiest tyrants in the history of the world he was the absolute ruler of the soviet union and later of the communist bloc in easter europe.
If trotsky had won the power, and attempted to spread communism over the world, war would have been inevitable 'socialism in one country' was due to this he did not succeed to become the leader of the bolsheviks party the statement stalin won because trotsky lacked a power base does not. Because trotsky missed lenin's funeral it caused all sorts of problems for trotsky in the future he was thought to be insecure comrade stalin having become the general secretary has immeasurable power in his hands, and i am not sure he knows how to use that power with sufficient. Trotsky lacked this level of duplicity i think this would have proved fatal in dealing with hitler it was stalin's devious mind which may have saved without stalin, there was a possibility of trotsky keeping a powerful position on the politburo, perhaps with some leading influence, but being only one. Stalin won because trotsky lacked a power base: how far does this statement explain why stalin, rather than trotsky, succeeded lenin as leader of the soviet state a power base is the source of a person's organisation power or influence.